Have you ever felt like you’re constantly telling your dog what to do? “Sit… wait… leave it… come here… no!” If you find yourself in a constant loop of commands, you’re not alone. Most dog owners believe that guiding their dogs every step of the way is the key to good behaviour.
But what if the real magic happens when we take a step back?
What if we taught our dogs how to make the right choices on their own?
This is where confidence building comes in — helping dogs learn through decision-making rather than direction alone. And once you understand how powerful this approach can be, you’ll not only have a well-behaved dog, but also one that’s confident, relaxed, and mentally fulfilled.
Why Choice Builds Confidence
Just like humans, dogs thrive when they feel a sense of control over their environment. When we constantly micromanage them, we rob them of the chance to think and learn.
Imagine a toddler who’s never allowed to choose their own toy, pick their own clothes, or explore the garden without being told what to do. Eventually, that child becomes anxious, uncertain, or overly dependent on others for direction. The same applies to dogs.
Confidence is built when a dog:
- Is presented with a situation
- Considers what to do
- Chooses an action
- Is rewarded for getting it right
This doesn’t mean letting them run riot. It means creating safe environments for decision-making and then marking and reinforcing the correct choices.
What Kind of Choices Are We Talking About?
You’re not handing over your house keys here. These are small but meaningful moments in your dog’s day where they get to think before reacting.
Here are some common examples:
| Scenario | Old Way | Confidence Building Way |
|---|---|---|
| Guests arrive | Tell dog “go to bed” repeatedly | Let them choose their bed, reward the moment they do |
| See another dog | Pull them back & say “no barking!” | Let them look, wait, reward calm behaviour |
| Walks | Constant “heel!” cues | Give some lead length, reward when they choose to walk calmly |
| Approaching a distraction | Repeated “leave it!” | Say nothing, mark & treat when they voluntarily ignore |
These moments give your dog a chance to learn what you want — by discovering it themselves.
How to Create Decision-Making Opportunities
Confidence isn’t built in chaos — it’s built in calm, clear, structured moments. Here’s how you set the scene:
🟦 1. Set Up a Safe Learning Environment
Start in places with fewer distractions. Indoors is ideal to begin with, or a quiet garden. You’re not throwing them into the deep end — you’re building a strong foundation.
🟦 2. Use Calm Observation
Let your dog assess the situation. Don’t rush to intervene. If they glance at the bin but walk away, you’ve got a teachable moment. Say “yes!” or click, and reward. The more this happens, the more confident and capable they become.
🟦 3. Catch Them Doing it Right
This is the heart of the method. Mark the behaviour you like, even if it was by chance. Over time, those “lucky guesses” become intentional behaviours.
⚡️ Confidence grows in the quiet moments when your dog realises, “I figured that out myself!”
Real-Life Confidence Builders
Here are some everyday ways to help your dog make great choices:
✅ The Sit Before the Lead
Instead of demanding a sit, simply stand quietly. Wait for the sit — even if it takes a minute. As soon as they offer it, clip the lead on. You’ve just taught them how to earn the next step.
✅ The Wait at the Door
No need to repeat “wait… wait… wait…” Just open the door slowly. If they charge, close it gently. Try again. The moment they pause, praise and open it wide. Over a few sessions, you’ll see the pause offered every time.
✅ Meeting Other Dogs
If your dog is reactive or excitable, give space. Let them look. Don’t jump in with corrections. When they glance and then choose not to bark or lunge, reward that restraint. This is huge for their confidence.
✅ Choosing Calm
Dogs often pace, bark or fuss when they want attention or stimulation. Ignore the chaos — then calmly reward moments of stillness. They’ll quickly realise calm choices = positive outcomes.
When to Step In
Of course, there are times when we do need to guide our dogs:
- Dangerous situations (e.g. eating something unsafe)
- Escalating reactivity or aggression
- New or unfamiliar environments where safety is unclear
In these cases, you still provide direction, but return to confidence-building when things settle.
If your dog struggles with emotional regulation, fear, or aggressive responses, don’t go it alone.
A professional behaviourist can create a tailored plan that builds confidence safely and gradually.
👉 If you need expert support, visit www.simplydogbehaviour.co.uk and get in touch.
Why Confidence Trumps Obedience
You could teach your dog a thousand commands — but what happens when you’re not there to issue one?
A confident dog doesn’t wait for instructions.
They choose the right thing because it makes sense to them. That’s the real win.
- Less barking
- Less stress
- Fewer battles of will
- More calm, trust, and connection
And best of all… it’s a dog who trusts themselves and you.
Want to Start Early?
Confidence-building doesn’t have to wait until adulthood. In fact, the earlier you begin, the better.
If you’ve got a puppy between 8 and 20 weeks, our 30 Day Puppy Plan teaches you how to build these habits from day one.
The plan gives you step-by-step guidance to raise a calm, confident puppy who loves learning and exploring the world.
Final Thoughts
Confidence isn’t taught through control. It’s nurtured through trust, encouragement, and the freedom to think.
Helping your dog make the right decisions on their own is one of the most rewarding parts of being a dog owner — for both of you.
Thanks so much for reading!
If you found this post helpful or insightful, please share it with fellow dog lovers.
That’s how this blog grows — not through ads, but through real people like you. 🐾